A second set of Twinkle-Eyed ponies were released in Year 5, between 1986 and 1987. Like the ponies in the original Twinkle-Eyed set, these ponies all had colored plastic jewels in their eyes and four different colors in their hair. Speedy had already been released in the Year 4 set, but the other ponies in the set were all new. Each pony came with a ribbon and a comb or brush, and some packages also included a pamphlet.
Locket is a pink adult Pegasus pony with iridescent dark pink eyes. Her hair is striped white, pink, peach, and lavender. Her symbol is three keys, two dark pink, one lavender. She stands in the Locket Pose. Locket came with a lavender sun pick and a ribbon.
Tic-Tac-Toe is a yellow adult earth pony with iridescent orange eyes. Her hair is striped red, dark pink, dark green, and green. Her symbol is a tilted green Tic-Tac-Toe board with red X's and O's. She is in the Sugarbery Pose. Tic-Tac-Toe came with a bright purple star brush and a ribbon.
Quackers is a white adult earth pony with iridescent green eyes. Her hair is striped blue, green, yellow, and dark pink. Her symbol is a yellow and orange duck carrying an orange umbrella with yellow stripes. She is in the Quackers Pose. Quackers came with an orange sun pick and a ribbon.
Bright Eyes is an ashy-blue adult earth pony with iridescent pink eyes. Her hair is striped white, light yellow, orange-red, and red. Her symbol is a red and white alarm clock. She is in the Crumpet Pose. Bright Eyes came with a yellow star comb and a ribbon.