These are the ponies on our current want list. We're not picky collectors, and we're often happy to accept ponies with haircuts, dry hair, flocking wear, symbol or eye scratches, fading, chew marks, or minor body marks. We're also happy to trade for ponies on our sales page. For sales, we prefer PayPal.

     Looking to sell or trade something from our list? Great! Just drop us an email with pictures or a description, and your preferred prices/trade offers. (Please don't ask us to make you an offer -- let us know how much you're asking for the pony, and we can tell you if it's in our price range.)

     Scroll down the list for:

US Ponies | Special Offer | UK and Europe | Nirvana Ponies | Dream Beauties | Petites | Plushies | Soft Sleepy Newborns | Playsets & Accessories | Merchandise | MIP Ponies

---

U.S. Ponies

 
Ponies and Pony Friends

• SS Fifi
• Diamond Dreams
• Frilly Flower
• Love Petal
• Baby Pockets
• Cha Cha the Llama
• Oakly the Moose
• Pearly the Fancy Mermaid Pony

 
Sea Ponies

• Seabreeze
• High Tide
• Whitecap
• Wave Jumper
• Sea Mist
• Sand Dollar
• Baby Sunshower
• Baby Wavy
• Baby Seabreeze

 

Special Offer Ponies

• Sweet Scoops
• Rapunzel
• Stockings the Christmas Pony
• Hollywood
• Clipper
• Baby Up Up and Away
• Baby Pony ("Beachy Keen")
• Lil' Cupcake
• Baby Sugarcake
• Baby Gametime
• Non-BBE Baby Half Note

 

International Ponies

 
Early Ponies

• Non-BBE Baby Heart Throb
• Baby Honeycomb
• Baby Cherries Jubilee
• Baby Buttons

• Wave Breaker (and yellow clam shell)

• Raindrop
• Nightlight

• Ice Crystal
• Fireball
• Tornado

• White Baby Pony
• Baby Bridesmaid
• Baby Fun n' Games
• Baby Ribbons n' Hearts

• Cascade

 
1991-1992 Ponies

• Love Letter

• Patch
• Bon Bon

• Starlight (Hairdo Pony)

• Baby Würfelchen (blue Nestäckchen baby)
• Baby Schlummerlein (yellow Nestäckchen baby)

• Daddy Meadowsweet
• Daddy Sunbright
• Daddy Berrytown

 
1993 Ponies

• Baby Licorice

• Baby Splish
• Baby Splash
• Baby Splosh

• Baby Sapphire
• Baby Diamond

• Highlights (Great Hair Pony)

• Nurse Tenderheart
• Nurse Sweetheart

• Baby Cuddles (Surprise Newborn)
• Baby Snoozy

 
Dutch Alternate Ponies (1995)

• Singalong Pony
• Star Pony
• Shell Pony
• Diary Pony
• Butterfly Pony

• Baby Dolphin Pony
• Baby School Pony
• Baby Flower Pony

 
Alternate Birthflower Ponies

• January (Carnation)
• February (Violet)
• March (Daffodil)
• May (Lily-of-the-Valley)
• August (Poppy)
• September (Morning Glory)
• October (Cosmos)
• November (Chrysanthemum)
• December (Holly)

 
Nirvana Ponies

• Brazilian Ponies
• Argentinean Ponies
• Peruvian Ponies
• Venezuelan Ponies
• Other international variant ponies

 

Other Vintage Pony Items

 
Dream Beauties

• Circle Dancer
• Colorglow
• Sheertrimmer
• Mane Waves
• Spritzy
• Windwalker

 
Plush Ponies

• Moondancer (open-mouth version)
• Cotton Candy (Applause version)
• Baby Lickety-Split

 
Soft Sleepy Newborns

• Sweet Dreams
• Pink Dreams

 
Petite Ponies

• Click here for our Petite Ponies Want List

 
Playsets and Accessories

• Click here for our Playsets and Accessories Want List

 
Vintage MLP Merchandise

• Lil' Litters
• Porcelain Ponies
• Coloring books
• Storybooks and picture books
• UK Annuals and other booklets
• Pamphlets and flyers
• Puzzles, games,
• Pony Wear and Pretty Ups
• Other merchandise including games, puzzles, party favors, vintage clothing, bedding, office supplies, kitchenware, etc.

 
Mint-in-Package Ponies

• We're looking for almost any MIP ponies at reasonable prices. We prefer packages with minimal yellowing and no major cracks to the plastic bubble. Some wear to the box/card is okay.